| Season 58 (2007-08) | Season 59 (2008 - 2009) | Season 60 (2009-2010) |
| High School Musical Treasure Island Singin' in the Rain Tom Sawyer |
Footloose Oliver! Titanic, the Musical Once Upon a Mattress |
Fame, the Muscial Noises Off Mame To Kill a Mockingbird |
| Season 57 (2006-07) | Season 56 (2005-06) | Season 55 (2003-05) |
| The Music Man* Oklahoma!* The King and I* |
The Sound of Music Midsummer Night's Dream A Christmas Carol |
Joseph & The Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat* Misery Nuncrackers To Kill a Mockingbird Smokey Joe's Cafe To Gillian on Her 37th Birthday Blood Brothers The Rocky Horror Show* Annie |
| Season 54 (2002-03) | Season 53 (2001-02) | Season 52 (2000-01) |
| Babes In Toyland Crazy for You The Importance of Being Earnest* Masterclass Much Ado About Nothing The Rocky Horror Show* |
An American Daughter Assassins Dracula* The Miss Firecracker Contest Oliver* Rags |
42nd Street 84 Charing Cross Road Alice In Wonderland Damn Yankees Getting Away With Murder Gypsy* |
| Season 51 (1999-2000) | Season 50 (1998-99) | Season 49 (1997-98) |
| An Inspector Calls* Anything Goes The Last Night of Ballyhoo The Music Man* One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest Side Show |
Amadeus La Cage Aux Folles Song of Jacob Zulu Steel Magnolias Sylvia Wizard of Oz |
The Boys Next Door Bye Bye Birdie Day In Hollywood, Night in Ukraine Little Women A Piece of My Heart Rumors Sweeney Todd |
| Season 48 (1996-97) | Season 47 (1995-96) | Season 46 (1994-95) |
| Cinderella Lend Me A Tenor Miss Evers Boys On Borrowed Time Rodgers & Hart: A Celebration Secret Garden |
A Few Good Men Best Christmas Pageant Ever Haunting of Hill House Into The Woods Shenandoah* The Sisters Rosensweig |
A Funny Thing Happened...Forum* Black Nativity* Dancing at Lugnasa Dial M for Murder I Hate Hamlet Man of La Mancha Three Musketeers |
| Season 45 (1993-94) | Season 44 (1992-93) | Season 43 (1991-92) |
| Black Nativity* The Diary of Anne Frank* Lettice & Lovage Noises Off The Piano Lesson Sweet Charity |
Brighton Beach Memoirs Hello Dolly Les Liaisons Dangereuses Little Shop of Horrors Prelude to a Kiss Summer and Smoke* |
Fences Mame The Man Who Came to Dinner Nunsense Pump Boys and Dinettes Purlie Towards Zero |
| Season 42 (1990-91) | Season 41 (1989-90) | Season 40 (1988-89) |
| Caberet* Camelot Deathtrap The Dining Room Kiss Me Kate* Peg of My Heart Twelfth Night* |
Brigadoon Bubbling Brown Sugar Joseph & the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat* The King and I Musical Comedy Murders of 1940 The Shadow Box* Wait Until Dark* |
A, My Name is Alice Dracula* Frivolities The Mousetrap My Fair Lady Pippin* The Unsinkable Molly Brown |
| Season 39 (1987-88) | Season 38 (1986-87) | Season 37 (1985-86) |
| Baby Best Little Whorehouse in Texas Cyrano de Bergerac* Gypsy* Mornings at Seven Playing for Time Witness for the Prosecution |
California Suite Company Dames at Sear Grease Inherit the Wind Romeo and Juliet Ten Little Indians |
1940's Radio Hour Agnes of God Candida* Cat on a Hot Tin Roof* Come Back to the 5 & Dime, Jimmy Dean Hot L Baltimore Oliver* |
| Season 36 (1984-85) | Season 35 (1983-84) | Season 34 (1982-83) |
| Carousel Children of a Lesser God Crimes of the Heart MacBeth* Oklahoma Once Upon a Mattress* Our Town |
A Little Night Music The Crucible The Fifth of July Flea in Her Ear Last Meet...If Knights...White Magnolia The Music Man* Shenandoah* |
Chapter Two Death of a Salesman Fiddler on the Roof The Gondoliers On Golden Pond Scapino Tintypes |
| Season 33 (1981-82) | Season 32 (1980-81) | Season 31 (1979-80) |
| Born Yesterday Candide* Dark of the Moon I Do, I Do Of Mice and Men See How They Run Who's Life is it Anyway The Wisteria Bush |
The Children's Hour* Godspell Promises, Promises Same Time, Next Year Sleuth Taming of the Shrew You Can't Take It With You* |
The Good Doctor Light Up The Sky* Mister Roberts Robber Bridegroom The Shadow Box* The Subject Was Roses* Sweet Mistress Vanities |
| Season 30 (1978-79) | Season 29 (1977-78) | Season 28 (1976-77) |
| Bus Stop The Innocents* Pippin* Private Lives* She Stoops to Conquer Sherlock Holmes Volpone |
A Thurber Carnival Blithe Spirit Harvey* In Fashion The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie The Rainmaker Two Gentleman of Verona |
All The Way Home The Amorous Flea The Contrast The Matchmaker The Rivals Six Rms Riv Vue Threepenny Opera* Veronica's Room |
| Season 27 (1975-76) | Season 26 (1974-75) | Season 25 (1973-74) |
| A Funny Thing Happened...Forum* A Man of All Season Bell Book and Candle* The Boyfriend Gift of the Magi St. Joan Subject to Change The Tempest |
The Giants' Dance Hedda Gabler* Lullabye Mary, Mary No Opera in the Opry House Prisoner of Second Avenue Rozencrantz & Guildenstern are Dead School for Scandal |
Antigone* Applause Arsenic and Old Lace The Diary of Anne Frank* Dinny and the Witches Hay Fever* How the Other Half Loves Kiss and Tell |
| Season 24 (1972-73) | Season 23 (1971-72) | Season 22 (1970-71) |
| Angel Street Any Wednesday Cabaret* Cat on a Hot Tin Roof* House of Blue Leaves The Imaginary Invalid Plaza Suite Wait Until Dark* You're A Good Man, Charlie Brown |
Design for Living Don't Drink the Water Friend of the Family Hadrian VII I Never Sang for My Father Little Murders Lovers Once Upon a Mattress* Twelfth Night* |
Cactus Flower Everybody's Girl Invitation to a March MacBeth* Out of Focus Summertree The War Minister You Can't Take it with You* Your Own Thing |
| Season 21 (1969-70) | Season 20 (1968-69) | Season 19 (1967-68) |
| The Apple Tree The Birthday Party Hamlet The Knack Lion In Winter The Odd Couple The Skin of Our Teeth* Sweet Bird of Youth |
A Case of Libel After the Rain Everything in the Garden Generation Happy Haven Luv Of Thee I Sing U.S.A. |
A Delicate Balance Biography Guys & Dolls House of Bernada Alba Major Barbara Oh What A Lovely War Slow Dance on the Killing Ground |
| Season 18 (1966-67) | Season 17 (1965-66) | Season 16 (1964-65) |
| The Entertainer Good Woman of Setzuan Kaleidoscope Kiss Me Kate* The Seagull Streetcar Named Desire* The Subject was Roses* Under Milkwood Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf? |
110 In the Shade The Firebugs The Hostage Night of the Iguana Oh Dad, Poor Dad The Physicists Sunday in New York Visit to a Small Planet The Would Be Gentleman |
A Thousand Clowns Bells are Ringing The Children's Hour* Critic's Choice The Forest The Innocents* Leave it to Jane Period of Adjustment Three Men on a Horse* |
| Season 15 (1963-64) | Season 14 (1962-63) | Season 13 (1961-62) |
| A Shot in the Dark The Caretaker Come Blow Your Horn The Fantasticks I Am A Camera The Man in the Dog Suit Member of the Wedding Riverwind Tea and Sympathy |
The Busy Martyr The Cocktail Party* Once More with Feeling Paint Your Wagon The Rose Tattoo Send Me Flowers Threepenny Opera* |
A Hateful Rain As You Desire Me The Fifth Season Lo and Behold Night of the Auk Pajama Game Pygmalion Royal Gambit |
| Season 12 (1960-61) | Season 11 (1959-60) | Season 10 (1958-59) |
| A Sleep of Prisoners All the King's Men The Little Foxes Man and Superman Night Must Fall Private Lives* Will Success Spoil Rock Hunter The Women |
A Singer's Holiday A View From the Bridge Bald Soprano and the Submission Burning Bright The Deep Blue Sea The Importance of Being Earnest Mood for the Misbegotten The Solid Gold Cadillac Tartuffe |
A Clearing in the Woods Children of Darkness Relative Strangers The Skin of Our Teeth* Susannah |
| Season 9 (1957-58) | Season 8 (1956-57) | Season 7 (1955-56) |
| Antigone* Arms and the Man The Chalk Garden Champagne Complex The Constant Wife Janus The Master Builder Nina Tennessee Day in St. Louis Venus Observed |
The Father and Before Breakfast Getting Married The Gioconda Smile Hay Fever* The Little Hut Night of the Full Moon Pursuit of Happiness The Rebel's Revenge White Sheep of the Family |
Candide* The Confidential Clerk The Golden Apple The Hasty Heart Miranda Ring Around the Moon Southern Exposure Tobacco Road |
| Season 6 (1954-55) | Season 5 (1953-54) | Season 4 (1952-53) |
| Amphitryon 38 Animal Kingdom The Country Girl The Glass Menagerie Hedda Gabler* Misalliance My Three Angels |
Bell Book and Candle* The Cocktail Party* Cosi Fan Tutti The Curious Savage Don Juan in Hell Gigi Guest in the House Othello Philadelphia Story |
Androcles and the Lion Browning Version & Marriage Proposal Come Back Little Sheba For Love or Money Harvey* The Lady's Not For Burning Marriage of Figaro Second Threshold Streetcar Named Desire* |
| Season 3 (1951-52) | Season 2 (1950-51) | Season 1 (1949-50) |
| All My Sons Beautiful People East Lynne Fatal Weakness John Loves Mary Rope Summer and Smoke* Trial By Jury Years Ago |
An Inspector Calls* Clutterbuck Craig's Wife Light Up The Sky* The Male Animal Ten Nights In A Barroom |
Heaven Can Wait Home of the Brave Three Men on a Horse* |
